I was initially very confused about the connection between
the first three pieces and the last video—until I saw what the topic was: “Just
Dreamin’”. Ah, now it all makes sense. Between the first three media, I saw a
connection with race, or in this case racial minority. Also, the topic of rich
versus poor is seen in these pieces as well. In The House on Mango Street, Esperanza wants to escape her poor,
small, red house, not necessarily to be rich, but to be on her own in her own
home. That is her dream. And then in the New
York Times article, I linked the connection with minority race (or races)
and the poor trying to succeed in their goals—in this case three girls making
it through college. That article was very frustrating to read as someone who
relies on scholarships and financial aid myself. And then in the Chris Rock
video, Chris tries to get a wealthy neighborhood to change one of their main
boulevards to ‘Tupac Shakur Blvd.’ who was an African American rapper. From
what I saw, Chris mainly asked white and possibly some middle to upper class
people to sign the petition. Many of them completely rejected him, some
laughed, and some also agreed to sign his petition.
So far, in
all of these pieces we see similar dreams to escape poverty despite race or current
class; and then there is Chris Rock trying to move Tupac up into a class all
his own. But still moving forward. And if it had stopped here, I would have
expected the next piece to be the song “Movin’ on Up” by Ja’net Dubois (because
of the lyrics and the relation to race in the themed show “The Jeffersons”).
But no, we get Green Day’s “Wake Me Up When September Ends”. A young, white,
possibly lower class couple in which the boyfriend goes off to war. From what
the boyfriend says in the video, it seems a possibility that he agreed to go to
war to support the couple financially. Whether or not that is true, that is my
guess for the relationship between the video and the other pieces.
There are
correlations here between class and succeeding in school, class and race, and
the difficulty of “moving on up” in class, just within these three pieces. The
struggle to achieve dreams seems to be more difficult the lower the class one
is, and even more difficult when combining lower class with a minority race.
However, in
contrary to all of this and despite hurdles based on race or class, the people
in these pieces make attempts to overcome these challenges. We never truly find
out if the people in these stories “succeed” or fail, but that also depends on
each person’s definition of success. The girls in the NY Times article may have seen just getting into college as a
success. It all depends on the individual and what their dreams are. Some may
achieve those dreams, some may have changed their dreams, and some may still be
striving towards those dreams. It is all a matter of perspective. There will
always be difficulties, especially when it comes to race and/or class, but it
shouldn’t stop those from reaching for their dreams. Very inspirational.
No comments:
Post a Comment